“Life isn’t fair. It’s just fairer than death, that’s all”
- William Goldman, ”The Princess Bride”
Dear friend,
How are you? I am sorry I could not mail you for so long. I was having a lot of problems. I am Vivan, the 18 yr old boy. Do you remember me? We talked for sometime through e-mails a month or so back.
If you still remember me….. I want to thank you for your prayers. You were the only person who knew that I am a homosexual. Thanks for being there to listen to me. You were the only person who did not hate me for being gay. You were the only person who understood that being gay is not a curse; gays are not mentally retarded or physically handicapped. You were the only person who actually understood the pain and agony I was undergoing, probably because you have also undergone the same. Thank you so very much for being there for me and listening to me…
My parents saw some gay pictures I had saved in my computer. They were very angry. My dad nearly killed me that night. He hit me with everything that he could get a hold of. He even threw a tube light on my head but I some how saved myself from it. He even kicked me on my genitals. I was bleeding all over and my elder sister saved me from him. I was bleeding all over- my nose, my head, my mouth and my ears. My parents did not talk to me for the next two days. My dad took leave from office to make sure I was not given food and my wounds were not treated. My sister was asked to live with her friends. She was not allowed to see me. For two days I was not given food, I used to drink tap water secretly when my father used to go for a bath or fruits when my mother was not around. I thought of running away but I love my parents so much that I did not want to leave them. I cried so much that the tears had dried but my crying won’t stop. After two days, in the middle of the night my mother woke me up. She gave me two bananas to eat and some snacks. Though my hunger had died, I was glad that my mother was showing some love to me. The wounds of my mouth had not healed, so when I ate the salted snacks the wounds became red and it pained so much that I made a strangled cry. My dad woke up and beat me so hard that my left wrist fractured. The third day he talked to Mrs. Sareen, a very popular psychologist and teacher in my school, for advice. She must have told him about some hospitals in Bombay. My parents took me there. The entire journey my wrist ached. My parents ensured that I don’t talk to anybody. Everybody in the flight could understand that there was something wrong, but nobody cared to ask. We went straight to the hospital. I was kept under supervision of two ward boys in a storeroom for the entire day. They treated my wounds and fracture. Every one who enquired about me was told by the wardens that I am crazy. People used to look at me with disgust as if I was one. The entire day I thought about my childhood, the happy times of my life, all the expectations my family had from me. I blamed and hated myself for being gay. If I was not gay, all this would not have happened to me.
That night my treatment began. My X ray scan was taken followed by urine and blood tests. I was given an injection to sedate me as I was not able to sleep because of the panic and shock I was suffering.
“GOD!!! DON’T LET THIS HAPPEN TO ANYBODY!!!”
The next day I was woken up in the morning by the sound of an airplane. I saw the morning sun through my window. It was beautiful. The first thing I remembered was you, it made me feel nice because I knew if I told you what was happening to me, you would understand. The second thing I thought about was my first and only lip kiss in the 8th Standard with my friend Pavan. It was with him when I realized I am gay. Somehow thinking about my time with him and about you brought a smile on my face. And suddenly I started crying. The pain was unbearable. I turned to go back to bed but suddenly I felt dizzy and fainted. I gained conscience when the doctor sprinkled water on my face. I was tied to the bed. I could not even move my head. He gave me two injections. And then… the most painful treatment began… I was given electric shocks again and again and again. Even my lungs started to burn. As if the blood of my whole body used to boil every time they gave me shock. I wanted to shout, I wanted to stop them. I wanted to hide in my mother’s arms. But I could not say anything. They continued to give me shocks till I fell unconscious. My gums, legs and arms were swollen because of the shock treatment. I was not even able to walk or even hold anything. I can’t tell u how much it hurt.
In the evening I was taken to a doctor, on a wheel chair who talked about my sexuality. I was having so much of pain that I could not understand what he was saying. My father was sitting behind me. I wanted to tell him that I am sorry that I am gay. I didn’t want him to be ashamed of me. But all I did was to stare at the doctor. He told me that if I don’t “change” he will give me another round of shock treatment. I agreed to do everything he said. He talked about a lot of things but all I could think of was my dad, mom and sister Anna. That night my parents came to my room. My father told me that he will not consider me as his son if I don’t “change”. My mom was crying. She lovingly put her hand on my head and it felt like I should die this very moment. I am giving all the pain to such loving parents. I hated myself like anything.
The next day I was given bath after 4 or 5 days. My dad brought ‘Dosa’ for me and the taste was heavenly. I was taken to the doctor. The doctor talked a lot asking me about any sexual experiences, masturbation or molestation. Then he showed me pictures of beautiful girls and asked me how I felt about them. He then started showing me photos of nude girls, telling me fantasies of how I should make love to them. I started crying but he went on mentally pressurizing me. I tried to run out of the room but he called the ward boys who took me to the shock treatment room. I was once again given shock treatment. After I fainted, he sprinkled water on my face and once I gained consciousness, he started his treatment again. This went on, I can’t tell how long. I was bed ridden for the next 3 days and had already lost the track of time. My whole body was in pain. The nurse used to put water in my mouth sometimes. My thirst and hunger was eating me, but the pain in my heart was slowly killing me…..
Why was God doing this to me? Where did I go wrong? Am I so bad that I should be given so much pain? Why has God made me like this? And many more questions seemed to stare at me awaiting an answer. My past, present and my future were staring at me. As if the time had come to a stand still. I was feeling lonely. I would have killed myself if I could get up….
These three days were full of silence. I thought a lot. I thought about how I used to jerk off thinking about my Physics teacher or some handsome men. How I got an erection seeing my class mates. There was no doubt I was gay. I liked men. How can I “change”? Is it impossible for me to change? I don’t want to die like this. I don’t want electric shocks. I don’t want to have this pain. There are so many gays in this world. Being gay is not a sin! Oscar Wilde was gay. Alexander was gay. Caesar was a bisexual. Alfred Marshall and Adam smith were gay. Iliad and Odyssey talked about gay sex. Kama sutra talks about homosexuality. Even God Zeus made love to his daughter’s husband. There are European cities which are full of gays. A lot of countries show tolerance towards gays! So why should I be hated for being gay?
I woke up early morning. There was pin drop silence. The sun had not risen. I gathered strength to sit up. Somehow I felt stronger. What next? This was all I could think of. I remembered the lines I once heard: “if where you are, makes you who you are, then what you want to be is what u eventually become.” I thought,” I am not a bad person. I have not done anything wrong! God made me gay! If this world and my parents can’t accept it, I can’t help it either. I am not going to kill myself everyday or live with the fear of being hated! I am gay- this is me! And if you have to love me, love me as a gay, love me for who I am. And if u can’t – you don’t love me enough. I don’t remember when I fell asleep….
That day the doctor woke me up. I hated his face! Motherf****, daughterf****, sonf****, bloody bast***! I can’t tell u how much I hated him. I wish I could kill him!
The warden took me to the washroom, cleaned me up. I was given lime water to drink till I vomited, so that all the acids were thrown out. Then I was given food. That motherf*** doctor asked me to cooperate with him in “changing” me or he will continue giving me shocks. He said I am wasting my youth. Every word he uttered made me mad. I was angry! I was going to attack him and kill him but just then, my dad came in! It felt as if I was seeing him after generations! All the anger turned into emotions and I started crying. I shouted to dad and begged him to forgive me. I was his son. I know it was hard for him to see me suffer. I told him “I am sorry”. Even he started crying, and ordered everyone to go out of the room. He said he will take me home if I tell him that I have “changed”. I could not believe it. My dad who was proud of me one month back hates me so much!!! He wants me to “change” as if I had a choice. Can’t he feel the pain I am suffering? Is this not my life? At that moment, everything became clear to me! He wants me to change because he does not want to give up on his expectations. He is scared my homosexuality will change his life too. The problem is not me, the problem is he! It is hard for him to bear the shame of my homosexuality. That was the most painful moment of my life! I am ready to sacrifice everything for my parents. I could die for them. But my sexuality is a part of me. God made me like this. How can they blame me for being gay? Do I have a choice? If they really want my happiness, if they really love me enough, why don’t they accept me who I am! True love is only when you accept a person as who he is! I will hide it no more! I will not give up on myself! My homosexuality- bliss or curse; it is what makes me complete. I am not going to endure this much of pain. I give up! My heart ached so much that I could not speak. I just turned my face from him. He went out of the room crying…
I was alone in the room for a very long time. I wished all the men and women would turn into homosexuals and this idea made me laugh! And suddenly I was laughing uncontrollably for a long time. Then suddenly I stopped. What was happening to me? Was I becoming mad? I wish I could die, and I started crying. Then the doctor came in again. He showed sympathy towards me and told me that I need not be sad about being gay. He said that there are a lot of gays in the world. I looked at him amazed. ‘So he knew all about gays and still he is giving me this treatment! I tried to get up to beat him but lost my balance and collapsed. I scolded and cursed him and his family. He stood there for a long time and when I stopped shouting he kicked me on my chest. The wardens came and put me on bed. I cried and they tied me to bed so tightly that I could not even move. Eventually I went to sleep.
I had a dream. I saw that I was running a race and my parents were cheering for me. I won the race and when I was about to touch my parents feet, Pavan (my first kiss) came and took me in his arms and kissed me. Everybody started clapping. My dad smiled and said, “Son, Life is full of unexpected things, you can never know what life gives you but you have to take the best out of it and never stop daring, never give up.” I was woken up at night by a ward boy. He was young and sympathized with me. He did not know why I was here. He spoke to me for sometime. I was smiling when he went away. After he left, I suddenly realized I was lonely again.
The next morning my Mom and Dad woke me up. My mother told that she can’t bear my condition. She indirectly told me that I should lie to dad and tell him that I have “changed” or else she would die. The doctor was on leave for two days, so my mother and I had some time to convince dad. My dad was not really happy but he too wanted to get out of this mess. I was too weak to move or do anything. So I was admitted to another hospital for recovery. My fracture had become really serious. I was advised bed rest for a month but I recovered in a week.
My dad is not convinced by my assurance that I have “changed”. My mother is very worried about who will carry our name forward, a name taker through marriage as I will not be able to reproduce. But I am trying to convince her that science has the answers to her questions. She is not pro-adoption and unable to understand anything about homosexuality, but trying her level best to understand me. I got out of the hospital a few days back. I am living with my cousin and her husband. Anna (my sister) is not very happy with the news that I am gay. I have not met her for such a long time but I know she will understand me. My dad is taking me back home soon. I know things are not going to be the same between dad and me. But I know that big changes need big sacrifices. My mother and sister will support me. I would say it is a good starting as I have already suffered the worst. I know gradually my mother, sister and I will be able to convince my dad and make him accept my sexuality.
I don’t know how long will I take to email this letter to you and I don’t think I will ever be able to meet you. I don’t want to meet you also, because I want to love a boy of my age. I don’t remember your age but I know you are 4-5 years older than me. But I want to be your friend and maybe have sex also, but I don’t want to love you. Please don’t get hurt. I like you a lot. I will not be able to forget this time of my life. It was the worst, but my mind is very clear now. I know I will be fine and gay lifelong. There is no fear, no suffocation… And soon there will be no lack of love…
I am Vivan. If you still remember me, please reply. You are my only gay friend. And thank you a lot for being there..
Yours Vivan
That was the last time I ever heard from him. I sent him several emails to know how he was, and if he was being treated well by his family. But when I failed to get a response, I decided to seek help from another online friend who happened to live in the same town. Coincidentally, the guy turned out to be Vivan’s classmate and admirer. He was, to my utter surprise, Pavan- the first kiss boy of Vivan. Pavan used to visit Vivan’s house and update me on his health and recovery. But still there was an unflinching desire burning in me, a thirst to talk to my Vivan, to listen to his stories of torture and tribulations. I wanted to steal him from his family and take him away from everyone who hated gays. I wanted to pamper and cuddle him, prepare warm soup and feed him while we sat in our own little chalet overlooking two mountains. I wanted to be with him and make him forget his past.
A month had gone by. One afternoon our mutual friend Pavan called me. I picked up the phone with an ineffable alacrity as if my sixth sense had shrugged me up from slumber. He was quiet for a few seconds and then wept bitterly. I felt bile rising in my throat and I felt choked. “Vivan is no more…..he was on his bike when a truck ran over him…Death on the spot…He had a friend with him who survived. He was serious but doctors say he will survive…it happened yester…………….” The rest of the words seemed to fade away somewhere as if I never cared for the rest or for any other life form. I didn’t remember when Pavan hung up; I was still holding the mobile in one hand and a piece of black forest cake in the other. It was his favorite too…
For everybody, he died in an accident; we all knew that he was a reckless biker. He told me how he enjoyed speeding his bike with his shirt unbuttoned only to seduce the other boys around. But for me he neither died in an accident nor committed suicide. He was murdered 2 months ago by his parents, by our ignorance, by us…
He lost his life and I lost my ‘first true gay friend’ forever…
![]()
I am totally speechless.. Just realised that sometimes tears are really uncontrollable..
Vivan definitely was a matured character. Let lord give him all the freedom he wanted atleast in his next life..
Sadly, this is the case with most of us – in India..
We love our parents so much that we do not want to hurt their feelings & at the same time – cant help our sexuality.. God has made us this way to face the challenge & we have to deal with it. Each one of us take our own ways.. Some succeed & some fail miserably..
Some suffer silently & some cherish… I think I faced both of these.. Till I passed my technical education I was too scared & embarressed to even think about it.. It was only after I moved to Bangalore I got to have a bigger picture of this unique world.
In the span of the small time – I have realised that its very tough to get a gay man as a good friend since most of the times the intention is totally different.
The initial impression of this new world was really bad. The obviously apparent dirty attitude of most of them made me feel sick to consider myself a part of this world.
But soon I realised that there are good & wise people in this awefully mean world too..
I am lucky to have found quite a few really good friends in this otherwise hopeless world..
My words to the people who are new to this: Welcome to this new world! You will love it.. Just remember that there are some shitty people out there – both gay and straight and you might meet those ones first, but don’t get jaded. In time you’ll meet some of the best people in your life…. Promise. . . .
Thank you very much.. You are the first reader to comment. M glad that you felt it.
This is extremely saddening and truly horrific, I wonder what Vivan was made of, he went through such an ordeal without a breath of rebellion.
It is sad that being gay is considered a curse, evil, by many, but they don’t realise we’re human. The saddest part is that Vivan is ill-treated by his own father, how can people get this selfish? Can’t they just live and let live? It’s such a pity. Each and everyone in the society who thinks being gay is BAD must be enrolled into some kind of reforming programmes, so that all the Vivans out there are safe and can express their feelings without hesitation. We must get a status in the society and all the rights we deserve! I don’t think we’re working towards it, though.
I don’t know when the society will transform itself, I just know that it is going to be a long process, we cannot expect people to accept us instantly. It’s been a battle for all of us since eons and it shall sadly remain one forever.
Hi, Gibben.. Thanks for your comments. I completely agree with u. You are right. Yes our society does not accept it, neither do our own parents and family. But the truth is, this kind of reaction does not surprise me. A society that forbids indecency, public display of affection and any form of moral behaviour between 2 consenting adults is totally indifferent to increasing rapes, molestation, paedophilia and even sati. India has a long way to go before it realises that being independent is not being free. I have been in Europe for a while, although I still love my India the most!, I love staying in Europe. Because I prefer living as a free foreigner than a caged citizen. I must say that it is not the society or parents antipathy towards us that troubles me more. It is actually the Indian gays as individuals, their voracious appetite for easily available sex and sexual depravity, infidelity, one night stands, parallel lifestyles after marriage, and the tendency to treat other gays like garbage…thats what hurts me most.
If you have any topic to discuss and wanna post it lemme know. I will have it posted after reviewing the content under your pseudo name. TC
It was a painful saga
i wish atleast now vivian would rest in peace
i was crying when i read abt vivian’s death..no i dontk now him….most of our lifes would be the same thing if we come out to our parents…hence dont know what to do……
Gay [Adj.]… “Happy” … one of the meanings in dictionary…
Gay [Noun]… w.r.t present situation as of in India… the meaning is very different from what it means as an adjective.
Its a long way.. where we can think that this word does not hold any significance.
The vision – A person wont be classified as Straight, Gay, Bisexual… A gay is just another person….
Are we expecting too much!! Its not our expectation.. its our right!
To Chandan,
Whenever you donno wat to do, close ur eyes before going to bed and ask your heart, urself as an individual and u will have ur answer. I promise…
It would be unjudgemental to say our consequences wud be the same. Because we all are different people and so are our parents. They might not hug u in pride but might get hurt. So sometimes it is better to hide the truth forever…as long as u can. And leave it to fate… Remember u aren’t the worst liar as long as u don lie to urself.
Thanks for ur comments and expressing urself…
To Inaayat,
Very well said. Ur point is true but seldom thought about. Although, it is imperative that we don’t wait for others to accept ot reject us. Whats more important is we accept and love ourselves, whats more prudent is to create our own identity not by slogans or organising separate gay parties but by loving and finding the special someone, someone who u can trust, someone who cud hold ur hand and say “don worry, i m there for u”. I know finding that lover isn’t always easy but hey! who said that life was meant to be a fair game. Thanks for your comments and pls keep reading. The next article is not about sorrow but about joy… so cheer up!
La vie est belle!
Your welcome…like everyone i wud also like to know if ‘The Last Letter’ is true.
For me I have had my share of this beautiful feeling called ‘LOVE’. Fell for a guy who was not into guys. But the thing that went wrong was… i was too possessive. I was helpless… when u r in love… u tend to become possessive. Loved and lost… and now m myself trying to get away from him… long story…
Dont know how long will it take to find that someone who would say “dont worry, m there for u” in its trueness.
I felt I was complete when I was with him. Now, so lonely…
was waiting to let it out of my heart….plz ignore it!
Dear Inaayat,
This blog is all about life, about me and everything in this is true including the last letter. Yes I understand your feelings, what u r going thru. The last letter was not the end but the beginning of my predicament, things I don’t wanna remember, things and people who I might have forgiven but not forgotten.
There is a saying “Possessive lovers are the best lovers”. People often misunderstand them to insecured or suffocating but the truth is possessiveness is another form of a captive heart, a heart who loves deeply, endlessly and honestly. Yes ofcourse anything in excess is lethal, so instead of accusing urself of possessiveness try changing and expressing ur love in other ways.
Falling for someone who was not into guys: i would say is being naive because just the way no one can beat us to turn straight, same thing applies to others.
I understand the pain of being alone, the urge of having someone special, the need of having someone who wud tell you “i m there for u”. But it is no use getting impatient, things will happen when time comes; till then make urself a better man in ur own eyes.
Yes, improving day by day as a person is what even i believe in. And Yes, i too believe that everything has a right time. No one gets anything before till the decided “time” has come. Just do ur part honestly and expect nothing…sometimes [in my case most of the times] its difficult to not expect anything!
We know everything but still…thats life…
U take care.
Inaayat,
We are all on the same boat.. And apparently the same river. So don’t worry, we all will meet someone someday.
Hope so
Umeed pe duniya kayam he…
Inaayat,
Yes thats true. Neways, after receiving quite disturbing reviews and comments from all my readers, I decided to write something on the lighter side. Would appreciate if you read my new blog in ur free time and lemme know your views… I would be glad.
Thanks and TC
Hi
I have no words to say at this point. I am speechless, motionless. Friend we all are sailing in the same boat and we are facing the same crisis. Don’t loose hope and everything will work as the way you wish. Your feelings are pure.
do not worry. we all are with you and I am posting this mail in my community on orkut.
Community: Gay/Bisexual True Stories
Love you for what you are….Tuney
Tuney,
Hey thanks for reading and understanding and for your support. Appreciate that. I think I am already a member of ur community in orkut and posted my blog site there… You are also doing great deed.. Unlike other communities for sex, hookups and porn, ur community stands out… and I loved it. It is high time that we have more conscience, respect and morality for each other before expecting the world to accept us. I am glad we have guys like you. Take care.
Thanks again!
I read ur new story yesterday…[two days before.. its past midnight now
a journey into thoughts running in a mind...
what everyone [including me] would surely appreciate is the beautiful narration.
keep posting. Would love to read more on your pages!
Au revoir
It is a saturday morning today, and last night i was drunk, with lots of thoughts of solitude, hopelessness and love. But today morning you changed it all. Thanks a lot! It is a huge encouragement for me…
Yes the next one is soon to come… sexier and most importantly kinkier!
really i am speechless
ur narration is so great & sweet that i cant take break in bet
read the so different & sensitive story ( which is not containing any hug kiss shag & fuck) after so many days rather i would say for the 1st time
i think this story should be read by “SO CALLED NORMAL”
public also so that they can rethink on the view they take on HOMOSEXUALITY
HOPE THIS WOULD HAPPEN IN INDIA ALSO VERY SOON
THANKS AGAIN
pl do post such stories
T C
Rahulraj,
Thanks a lot! Your comments are very encouraging and very sweet.
Yes, I started this blog for men who value life and relationship and feelings. And also for those who don’t, so that may be someday after reading my stories they would decide to change or atleast see life thru a different perspective.
Take care.
Ofcourse I would wanna confirm that all writeups have been and will be true incidents…. So you might expect an instance related to hugs, kisses, shag and fuck.. But very importantly, they should not be perceived as porn but feelings of a man… After all, sex is a part of life and not life itself… Keep reading and let me know ur comments. I value my reader’s comments the most.
ur welcome…well u deserved it. It is a good narration.
Even I have felt sometimes rather many times; the state of mind/heart where one feels an uneasiness which is so difficult to describe to someone. You feel as if u shud talk to someone and tell that person what u r feeling at that moment. U expect something coming out of him [words] that would calm u..make u comfortable…lately i m going thru such situations more often. but never found that someone… to talk to….and as time passes by in that hour/day… everything comes to normal; atleast it seems to be normal…
Just wanted to share with you… there is a person.. i like him, whom i dont want to like… … his presence in front of my eyes disturbs me… Have u ever felt like this at some point of time?
U take care bbye
Inaayat,
Well before I answer to your question, I would want you to ask urself: Why you like that person?
1.Is it because he is good looking and handsome? If yes, would ur feelings for him continue even after he had lost it.
2.Or is it because he respects you and makes you feel nice? If yes, remember there is a thin line between respect and love. The former can exist without love but the latter needs respect. So don’t confuse his attitude towards you as love.
3.If there is a girl who is sweet and caring and loves you a lot. Can you make urself love her?
I guess when you answer all these 3 questions with honesty, you will be in a postion to judge ur feelings and emotions. Remember you can force neone to do the most unthinkable but u cannot force him/her to love you. Thats y love is so precious and so powerful…
If you are still not convinced, go and talk to him and tell him how u feel. If your love is true he will understand, else you will know where u went wrong.
Hello friend,
I come across so many blogs on the net everyday, but I am completely taken aback by the happenings as communicated by you through the letter. I am absolutely speechless at such atrocity! I knew India was anti-homo country but never could think that someone could punish his own child in that way for him being a guy, someone could be such insensible. I feel my heart going out for the little boy, and I really dont know how many such stories have happened here or are happening, it gives a tinge of stark reality, which one can’t just imagine but feel through your words. I have nothing to wish, as the boy is no more, but I wish you all the best in your life.
Life is really difficult when someone is gay and is in India, it will take eons for Indians to become more and more acceptable. When I talk with my straight friends and purposely try making discussions on gays, I just can feel the hatred they have in their mind, I also start hating them for this, but I cant express this, and I cant leave them as well, as they have been with me all these years, I just hope someday they understand what we go through, and how life is difficult for us.
Anyway, I would have really liked going on and on, but I know still I wont be able to express the emotions I have been going through after reading your post. Thanks for sharing something with us, and making us realize and feel how difficult life becomes when parents turn hostile.
Wish you all the best again.
take care
~ Sutirtho!
Thanks for your comments. Yes, you are right, life is really difficult for gays in India but honestly speaking I think the gays as individuals are to some extent responsible for what is happening and to a large extent the media. Today 80% of the gays think about sex, hookups and jerking off, they believe in all kinds of relationships inside the four walls and feel embarrassed to hang around with the same gays like friends do. I am not expecting them to come out and scream “We r gays”, all I am saying is that gays first should starting respecting and treating other gays as humans rather than sex objects and then probably oneday India will. Second the media, who I think is the biggest culprit. If I tell my parents about my sexuality I won’t be surprised if they misunderstand me as a enuch.. because media portrays gay men with twisted hands, lipsticks and an effeminate personality. These are the reasons my first gay friend fell victim to and I know that. Yes we indians are uneducated in many aspects of life, be it gays or women’s rights or even basic etiquettes on the roads. There are lot of things we cannot teach or force by law, but we can always show them things in a different perspective and leave it to them to choose. I have nothing against the effeminates, they r just like us but portraying the entire community in that light is hypocrisy. These are few things we will never find in Europe. And I love it for their tolerance and open mindedness.
As far as friends are concerned, please do not get angry or hurt by their hatred or homo phobia. Because just like there are lot of habits in our friends that we often despise, but we don’t leave them for that, similarly whether they are pro or against gays, it should not affect our friendship. One more thing, my best friend was homo phobic but the day I told him about me, he has made a conscious effort to accept this orientation. So you never know and you never should assume.
oh lover’s prayer,
what have u done? i m in tears, i cant believe vivan sent u a letter so painful…i never knew he was such a good writer, or i guess when things come from heart they r beautiful.
my hands r shaking even as i write, u just brought back vivan from death n killed him in front of me again…if he was ur first true friend, he was my first kiss too! a part of my heart always regret that i could never do anything to save him, it was my mother sho sent him to bombay…
but today, u have done something from him that has made him immortal. the world should know about him, n noone better than u to tell about him…an answer to his prayers.
i cant tell you how much it means to me…thanks a lot!
Love n Regards,
Pavan
So now u know y i wanted u to read and y i was angry… there are few things in life which at times u need to hold above the ur own feelings and emotions and priorities. No one is expected to be God, but it certainly makes a difference to listen to others at times… thanks for reading and i m happy u cried for him…. talk to u later
i was thinking how a human being can be so cruel? that fucking doctor was trying to change vivan? for what???? is not it just for money? ohh God! I wish i can get hold of that dirty ash!!! sorry for using such bad words……
Thanks for this post………………… i can just imagine it in my real life!!!! I have not told my parents that i am gay! but now i understand that its better that i dont tell them! its better to get hurt my myself than by others………
waiting for ur more and more posts!!!
No need to apologise.. i understand your anger and disgust. And about coming out to your parents… I guess it is a decision thats left upto u. I will never ever come out to my parents, not because i fear similar consequences but because i don wanna hurt them. As I stated in my blog, it is often better to lie than speak out truth..if it saves lot of life and keeps everyone happy.
I guess we r lucky to be educated and independent today or would be tomorrow..
Keep reading my other posts..hope u like it.
Hi Guys,
My friend in India forwarded me this link. And I thought *I* had a bad 22 years !!
. She even goes out of the way to fight with people who says nasty things about gays. When I went back to India for the summer, I remember mom and dad holding me and crying so much, not because I was gay, but because they had no idea and I had to suffer so long. Starting from my family to my cousins to my friends, everyone have been so supportive. So I can’t believe how lucky I am.
Needless to say I am gay. I knew I was since I was a kid and knew my parents would do something to change me etc etc if I told them. So I just took the first opportunity to get away…came here to the States for graduate studies. All the years from 7th grade till my first year her I was suffering from acute depression..and finally it took a toll, I went insane, made a suicide attempt on the 9h floor..but in the final moments I decided not to do it. And then I came out…or I was ‘outed’ whichever way it was. I assumed the worst; like parents disowning me, losing my scholarship etc etc. Well, and I was pleasantly surprised.
My school was so supportive..did everything to help, my friends from my undergrad in India came over to visit me in the hospital. They were disappointed that I hid something like this all these years thinking they would not be my friend any more. And then came the best ’surprise’. My mom, dad and sister…in a few insufficient words they could care less that I was gay or straight!. They just wanted me. And they could not simply live without me. Literally. Their reaction should not have been a surprise to me. I knew how they were all along..I was just too scared to see the truth. My sister is such a staunch supporter of me
That was one year ago. Now no more hiding or acting. And all the years I spent in the closet feels so damn strange now. It feels like some nasty nightmare that I was having and then I woke up. So now I am so happy. Mom and dad are looking forward to two son-in-laws(me and my sister).Now I have lots of friends here, gay and straight. Also I am dating.
Hope you guys also find the freedom and experience the happiness that I have found. It cannot be described.You have to experience it.
Peace.
And btw,
I have known him from my undergrad days.
He is the one who forwarded me this blog. Nowadays, I feel so normal and confident that I almost forgot how bad it was before and in turn forgot to appreciate how damn lucky I am. This letter, fabricated or otherwise, made me realize it all over again.
Hulo is my best friend
Now I will stop bitching about the little things that I do nowadays.(e.g. I dont like that guys teeth, I hate his eating habits and an endless list!)
Surya,
Reading your comments I feel that this should be considered as a post that stands opposite to the Last letter. Just to make people realise that there always was, always is and always will be another side of the coin. Yes, you are a lucky man..probably one in a million as far as indians are concerned. But then apart from being lucky one should also consider the fact that the circumstances you had created by your attempt to commit suicide might have had an impact. Probably the fear of your death overcast the fear of having a gay friend or gay son. Nevertheless, on behalf of all readers I am happy for you, and would wish things change for others too… Take care and keep reading. There are other posts too. Cheers!
Well, the fear of death is not necessarily true. You know why? Thinks did not happen in the exact order I said. I was depression for a long time..and I told them mom and dad over the phone much before my suicide attempt. Mom and dad was okay..the only thing they wanted was me to be happy. They already missed me a lot…but I guess I was not done with myself and had an internalized homophobia in me..and then finally a chain of events led me to try to jump off. But mom and dad knew long before that! Dad told me: “When God makes a pot, He makes the cover too. Likewise He will also make your counterpart. I haven’t sinned enough in my life so that God will create an empty pot for you without a covering”
And all these came from his heart. And all these happened before I tired to jump! And I would not even go to mom’s consolation.
It will be another Mahabharata!
But then why I tried the suicide? I think I was not done casting of the homophobia that the society has built into me. And now even if someone gives me the oppertunity of turning back the clock, I would not change that traumatic day. In essence,it marked the beginning of the best days of my life.
oh lol, I keep remembering old things now.
Just as the continuation as to why its not because of my suicide, I now remember several things mom and dad said. I remember since I was crying over the phone, unhappy as to why I was gay, mom and dad was crying too; I remember they siad it doesn’t matter…dad kept on saying “you don’t need to finish your PhD..you are more valuable..if staying there is so painful, just give it up and live with us…that way you will never be alone again”
I would get MORE upset with all these attempts to pacify me as I would think of being alone without any ’significant other’ for the rest of my life…and mom would start scolding dad. Then she would say that i am a man, and men don’t give up. SO I’ll complete my PhD and eventuality Mr. Right would also come along
. Yes, mom and dad are very candid with me. I just don’t know how it is possible for a traditional Bengali family.
Poor dad, he is never good in consolation
Ah! so u r a bengali? Hmmm me too… i hope my parents would accept me though i have not decided to come out… My prarents have been very open minded but cannot expect the same on this…
Lemme know how you found the other topics: memories, le soir en rose and foreever mine..Appreciate my reader’s feedbacks
heyyyyyyyyyyyyyy!! u r bengali!!! wow! so many bengalies around! lol
well Bengalis ARE the most liberal. In the time between I came out and my 9th floor ‘drama’ (as my friends call it), my father was making all efforts to really get to know what gay means, like if its a mental condition etc etc. So he went to a Doctor in Aurobindo Seba Kendra or EEDF. The doctor was quite mad or so my father said. The doctor said “If a gust comes to your house and at night instead of rice he wants rooti, will you call him carzy/perverted?? Then how come you call your son crazy and sick??”

Tonite I have a movie date and tomorrow I am going to a musical called ‘The Bathhouse’ with my friends. Lol The plot is “cute boy goes to a bathhouse to find love”..if you know what bathhouse really means here you will know how stupid and faggy the concept is.
Another friend of mine (Bengali too) came out. His parents had similar reaction to mine. and he did it without the drama.
I’ll read the other topics when I have time. Its been so busy lately.
and don’t judge people without the actual events have happened! You can not assume things and take it to be reality. You are no God! I am talking about your parents. See Bengali parents are TOO attached to their sons/daughters to think of anything else. They might initially be sad and ask you things abut eventually they will be like they SHOULD be. And moreover its unfair to assume things about people you are close to..especially if they are your parents.
its so touching.m cried whole night.my lover boy leave me in dis days.its al seems 2b my story
prakash,
well i m sorry if i made you cry.. although deep inside i feel successful when i m able to bring out the worst of man’s emations… I can understand what you are going thru. Well read the other posts, this might cheer u up a bit…although none of my posts are far away from sorrow
this story has really really moved me…and given me confidence.Reading this story only made my vision of introducing gay rights and LGBT marital right in my homeland,Pakistan,even more stronger.
I want say omethin which has come right from my heart:
Vivian hasnt dies..he’s still here,among us.He is one fortunate dro inan ocean which will one day give way to peace and tolerance towards homosexuals.
How honest he was! I can,and infact anyone can,judge it from his letter.
How do you know it was his parents who murdered him???just asking.
Vivian,if you are getting my words,ten know that you are one my heroes,and perhaps,the only gay one…
Hi,
Thanks for reading and commenting. Well when i say he was murdered, i don’t mean he was actually murdrered by his parents.. i mean what torture he went thru because of them… was almost same as murder, murder of his soul… I am glad i have a reader now from pakistan.. that sounds exciting!
Same here lversprayer.Its exciing to interact with an Indian blog writer and read is blog.I think his story his heart wrentching.But after every night theres a day,and so lets hope there’ll be one for evry other bisexuals,trannsexual and gay.
in between here is my blog on wordpress,in order that you might want to read it, i am leaving the address here:
http://www.usmann.wordpress.com
usmann,
Hey thank you!Sure i will read your blog… And we will be the blog buddies across the border
yeah sure..we’ll definitely be ‘Blog buddies’.and if we long enough and fate helps us out we’ll deifintely meet….
and in between i read you comment on my blog..you were definitely right in you opinion(which is a fact).and i commented back..
in between i seriously wanted to tell u that this last letter has defintely shcoked me and i was aghast to know that even our own parents can react like that…what barbarians vivian’s parents were…
oh and my name is osmman the blunt one..but i am the same usmann ….who has commented before..
here..i got my name back….
Hahaha! you got ur name back! Phew… it can be sometimes very difficult to get back what we loose.
Yes it is a shocking story… and strange. Afterall truth can be stranger than fiction.
Hey,
come on..you are right.Sometimes its difficult to get back what we lose.Even impossible.
But aslo sometimes its important that we let go of some things inorder to find peace.For that do go to my blog and read ‘Coming Out Of The Dark Closet’.you’ll understand what i mean.
Dont get disheartened.You are beatiful,no matter what they say.(listen to christina aguilera’s ‘Beautiful’.Its dedicated to you from me.
in between,will we always go on talking here,on blogs or is there a chance that we might become good friend?
awwww… cho cweet!! First time someone dedicated song to me…
I will read your blog.
Yes it is better to chat outside blog, this is just meant for comments
you have orkut profile then you can add orphandesire. My email is loversprayer@rediffmail.com
well…you are so sweet that anyone who be insane not to love you.and i’ll definitely add you.
also i have replied you on the both discussions where you posted your comments on my blog…..
keep visiting it….
luv ya.
bye
I am unable to articulate anything after reading this write up, read all the comments also.
May God rest Vivan soul in peace.
I cannot say anything beyond this.
Anonymous,
I understand your reaction and can comprehend it. No need for words. Vivan was my first gay friend… someone I loved a lot.
Keep reading and get to know more.
Part of our own lives.. if not physically.. mentally abused!!
May his soul rest in peace.. wid moist eyes..
Ajay
Ajay,
Thanks for reading and your condolences. You are right…. abuse is a part of our life…mentally or physically
Well. The best story I have ever read. Drops of the clear salty saline solution secreted by the lacrimal glands are unstoppable. I can’t really imagine that parents can be so harsh. Can they even hurt parts of their own soul, body in this manner? I am really scared [yeah, that word describes my feelings in the best possible way] and I am kinda thinking what would my parents do to me when they will come to know?
Anyways, may Vivan rest in peace. Souls which were made to suffer on earth by fellow human beings will be treated very well by the almighty in heaven. That’s what I can wish for.
clink of china,
Thanks for reading my post. I appreciate your feelings and condolences.. Well i guess all humans are different and so are parents…we never know how they will react. But yes, a note of caution before you decide to come out to them. My parents were most openminded of all… but when i came out 2 weeks back..the way they reacted; was something i have never expected. It will be on my next post.
just pray for God………………… one shudnt face such a miserable lyf
GOD BLESS HIM………………… wen he was alive never blessed him even GOD…………………..
Hope the world understand……………..HOw one is!!!! “Live n let Live”
read it….twice….don’t know what to say.
shylockholmes,
Thanks for reading.. I understand
It’s really painful…
I wish nobody in this world should make any Vivan go through all this…
Sandy,
Yes true, thanks for reading and commenting.